Tic, Tac, Toe - A Child's Game Or a Deadly Business Tactic

Being from a generation that inspired harmlessaway.
children's games like Tic, Tac, Toe,That was it.
Ring-around-the-rosy and later Battleship, it becameLet me ask you - if you were a CEO or Senior
clear later on in life that these games had applicabilityManager in this situation - how comfortable would you
to business. Of course, they took on different meaningbe that your primary people that interface directly with
and had more serious implications. The game of Tic,the target prospects and customers everyday
Tac, Toe has an interesting and predictable outcome,(representing your firm) were prepared to do battle
once you play it often and have an equal adversary -and end-up the Winner? If anything, it would seem that
it is called stalemate. No matter how you initiate theyou would be Victim not Victor - providing the
game, the outcome is the same - both players end-upCompetitor put more energy and brainpower into
in a draw. Just like real-world business, right? Notdeveloping a campaign (professionally) to exploit you.
exactly, however the desire in a business setting is toThere are a few quick questions to ask, at this point:
have an opponent that is less capable and possiblyHow much do your people really know about the
weak and vulnerable. That way the GAME - would beCompetition?
predictable and the Victor could walk away with all the(That includes fundamentals: Company history,
rewards.financials, useful stats, value proposition, product mix,
No pressure, little effort.sales tactics, make-up of the distribution channel and
Only if today's volatile Market Jungle worked that way.key Alliances, unique capabilities, breadth of customer
The challenge is that Competitors are not a roll-overbase, product roadmap, technology directions - futures,
and most companies approach the Game, with eitheretc.)
arrogance or fear.How does your firm respond when a Prospect refers
Either approach does not get the Win.to the Competition?
There are many articles, books and seminars that(Especially, if they ask you just to list three areas
profess the new wave approach to business -where your firm outshines them)
minimize the focus on the competition -avoid beingA useful exercise is to walk in unnanounced into your
preoccupied with them -rather concentrate on yourSales Bullpen and pose these questions to your key
own strengths, unique capabilities and providepeople - you will probably go into cardiac arrest, when
something distinguishable, which will stimulateyou recover from their responses.
Customers to beat a path to your door.It's not their fault - they are mature and proven
The Market will be yours.professionals - it is likely that there has not been
Great promise and it has become fashionable.enough attention put on these areas. Does your
Certainly, there are examples where this has worked -company invest in some level of training (consistently)
even examples where natural enemies collaborated,to allow your Team to keep pace and stay on top of
which is commonplace in the Defense and MilitaryCompetitors' movements?
Market.Incidentally - having a Product Manager or Director of
However, show me a successful company (thatMarketing get up at an annual Sales Meeting and have
means sustainable, not a one-trick pony ride) thata pre-wired, template that shows "worthless data"
ignored Competitive influences and tactics and I'll showabout the competition that is probably a year old and
you (consistently) a train wreck.flawed - is a tragedy.
How much attention should a company put on theHas your Company ever put a program or campaign
competition?in-place, which was designed to generate new
It depends on the dynamics of your Target segmentbusiness at your competitors' expense?
or niche and your company's appetite?If so, what was the outcome?
Do you seek leadership/dominance or are youIf not, why not?
satisfied being a participant or an also-ran? TheThis should be an element of your standard marketing
sentiments of your Senior Management Team or Topmix.
Dog (CEO) are also critical to defining and shapingChildren's games are harmless or that is what we are
molding how the rest of the organization views themade to believe, however what happens when they
Competition (and what they do about it).are carried into our mature business life?
Years ago, most organizations that we interfaced withLet's hope that Tic, Tac Toe does not turn into
would confirm that they were on-top of theirHangman in your Competitive circle.
competitors - meaning they were savvy andIn today's financial meltdown and tough Market
conversant about the competition.Economy, it is critical that there is a resurgence and
When we dug-in, we discovered that their Marketing,focus on the Competitive element.
Sales and Distribution Network had a few soundbitesDefine the customer's problem in your terms and you
about the Competitor, but were not equipped tohave a chance to Win.
outpoint and outmaneuver them.Allow the Competition to define the problem in their
There were soft indications that the Competition hadterms and "shame on you." What is your Company's
some feature set advantages or that they were usingscorecard on how well you are doing?
price tactics or unethical practices to take the business